Death in Fancy Dress (Anthony Gilbert)

  • By Anthony Gilbert
  • First published: UK: Collins, 1933
  • Availability: British Library Crime Classics, 2019, introduction by Martin Edwards

Rating: 3 out of 5.

The Spider strikes! A master blackmailer has fashionable London in his clutches; his titled victims are committing suicide in droves. The trail leads to Feltham Abbey, whose first owner shot himself during the War, and where a second violent death takes place on the night of a fancy dress ball. Somehow the fascinating Hilary Feltham’s love affairs are mixed up in the black business.

Death in Fancy Dress is the strongest of the early Anthony Gilberts I have read, but by no means is it a conventional detective story. It is more of a comedy of manners with murder. Gilbert’s early books tend to be rather staid procedurals, with grimly realistic character sketches of prostitutes, actresses, and London poverty; here she treats herself to a week in the country, in the company of bright young things, clever adventurers, and self-made millionaires. (Sayers praised the “remarkably well-drawn and sympathetic cast of characters”.) But it isn’t Gilbert’s most focused detective story; the death does not occur until page 129, and the culprit is disclosed 70 pages later. Although Gilbert has limited her scope for bamboozling the reader, she still manages to throw suspicion on all and sundry; everyone from tycoons and their charming sisters to the victim’s valet could conceivably be a blackmailer or worse. While she forces us to look elsewhere, X sailed past my nose, without any indication of guilt troubling the waters. Read and enjoy.


1933 Collins

During the last year the Home Office was greatly perplexed by a series of suicides and accidental deaths taking place among two definite sections of the community; on the one hand among men and women of rank and position, and on the other among the more well-to-do professional classes. Their investigations led them to Feltham Abbey, and when suspicion among the authorities was at its height Sir Ralph Feltham himself was found dead in very mysterious circumstances in the abbey grounds during a fancy-dress ball. There are several people who might have reason to wish Feltham out of the way: his cousin Hilary, because she was afraid of him; Arthur Dennis, because he loved Hilary and was jealous of Sir Ralph; Jeremy Freyne for the same reason. The story is told by one of the guests who is present at the abbey at the time, and as blackmail enters into the theme as well as murder, the reader can rely on having full value in this exciting and well-told mystery.


The Montrose Review (2nd June 1933): MURDER AT THE BALL.

Mr. Gilbert is an expert at this type of novel. His crimes are always interesting, and are solved in a logical manner. Death in Fancy Dress is, as the salesman puts it, “good value for the money.” The Home Office is at its wits’ end to discover the why and wherefore of a series of suicides and accidental deaths which have been committed among two distinct classes of the community, men and women of rank and position. and the well-to-to middle classes. These isolated incidents are finally linked up with the mysterious death of Sir Ralph Feltham, who is found dead in the Abbey grounds during a fancy dress ball. There are three or four suspects, and the story never loses interest. Nor is it without romance, for Arthur Dennis (one of the suspects) is in love with the dead man’s cousin. It is a tip-top yarn of murder and blackmail, and one of the best novels Mr Gilbert has yet given us. He certainly does this sort of thing very well.

John O’London’s Weekly (10th June 1933)

Times Literary Supplement (15th June 1933): A sudden wave of suspected blackmail leading to a series of suicides among persons in society and the professional classes were traced to Feltham Abbey, the home of Sir James Nunn, the tenant of Sir Ralph Feltham, a gentleman who had all the popular acquisitions of the villain, such as personal magnetism and bravery.  Hilary Feltham, Sir Ralph’s cousin, attractive, but rather a minx, was engaged to Arthur Dennis, of the Foreign Office, but she suddenly announced that she was going to marry Sir Ralph, which caused a great deal of heartburning at the abbey, where not the least of those affected was Jeremy Freyne, who had been fond of her for some years.  Sir Ralph, however, was found dead in a strange manner during a fancy dress ball at the abbey, and there are plenty of likely characters on whom the reader can try to fix the blame.  The story rather suffers from lack of action.

Daily Telegraph (16th June 1933): Tales of Mystery

Blackmail and murder figure in Anthony Gilbert’s Death in Fancy Dress, and Mr. and Mrs. Cole collaborate in a volume of short stories, in which that famous character of theirs, Superintendent Wilson, again proves an efficient sleuth. These stories are convincingly written, and keep the reader guessing most of the time.

Gloucestershire Echo (20th June 1933): Of more complex character [than John Rhode’s Claverton Mystery] is Death in Fancy Dress, by Anthony Gilbert, who has at least half-a-dozen good crime stories to his credit already. Several interesting characters come into this yarn in which blackmail as well as murder helps to swell the excitement.

Aberdeen Press and Journal (21st June 1933): From the Crime Club there come for June a very well-worked out case of Dr. Priestley’s, by John Rhode, who is now in the forefront of detective storywriters; a group of short stories, A Lesson in Crime, some of them very fascinating, about Superintendent Wilson, by G. D. H. and Margaret Cole; and a queer atmospheric thriller with quite unexpected ending, Death in Fancy Dress, by Anthony Gilbert.

Sunday Times (Dorothy L. Sayers, 2nd July 1933): Genuine Excitement

Death in Fancy Dress has at least one uncommon merit.  It contrives to persuade us that something really serious and unpleasant is taking place at Feltham Abbey.  So often in a detective story trivial irregularities like blackmail and murder seem scarcely to ruffle the placid current of domestic affairs, and the only person who displays any genuine excitement is the detective.  Here, the atmosphere of suspense and uneasiness really does pervade the household.  Setting aside the obvious “bad-hat” of the family, who is earmarked for trouble in any case, we are invited to select a murderer and society blackmailer from among a remarkably well-drawn and sympathetic cast of characters.  The choice is difficult (perhaps the blackmailer is made a little too sympathetic for absolute fairness), and the cleverest thing in the book is the way in which the heroine’s two lovers are played off against one another to the confusion of the reader’s critical judgement.  The writing is, on the whole, so good that I am inclined to lay the one or two syntactical howlers to the charge of the printer.

3 thoughts on “Death in Fancy Dress (Anthony Gilbert)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s