The Five Red Fingers (Flynn)

  • By Brian Flynn
  • First published: UK, 1929. Reprinted Dean Street Press.

South African millionaire Julius Maitland’s horse wins the Derby; his wife’s comes second. That night, the police receive a frantic call: “Help! Help! … I’m being murdered!” The police discover Maitland’s body, shot through the head – but he has been dead two days. Who killed him, and perhaps more importantly, is he still the Derby winner?

Flynn’s rather slow getting out of the gate; there’s too much detail about racing, betting, fetlocks and saddles for a non-horsey reader. But he soon picks up speed; Flynn sits well in the saddle, with a light, brisk style. He may not be a Christie thoroughbred, but he’s certainly not a draughthorse either. He is (bless him) a puzzle plot writer: detective Anthony Bathurst lists seven significant points, sits down and thinks, and writes the name of the murderer on a piece of paper (“Well, I’m damned!” says the police commissioner). He skilfully juggles hidden relationships and motives: an abandoned child here, a secret marriage there, and the mystery of the winning ticket holder.

Unfortunately, Flynn stumbles as he nears the finish line; he doesn’t come a total cropper, but it’s not the romp home one could hope for. I fell for the false solution; the deeper solution is unexpected, but unsatisfying. It feels like a contrived coincidence to pin the guilt on a minor character; the crime is unpremeditated / manslaughter (I like my murderers diabolically ingenious – they’re better quarry); and the clues are thin. I’ll accept the cobweb, but we should certainly have been told about the mackintosh sleeve.

This may not be a winner; it may not even place; but it’s an enjoyable day at the races. More like this – and I’ll be in like Flynn.

6 thoughts on “The Five Red Fingers (Flynn)

      1. that’s the one I really want to read as I have heard nothing but praise for it.

        Yes, I am familiar with Mr. Barge’s excellent site. Hats off to him for his efforts to bring Flynn back into print.

        Liked by 1 person

  1. Yeah, this isn’t the best from Flynn – in fact, there’s a good case that it’s the weakest of the first ten (or the first twenty, to be honest) The ending does seem to come out of nowhere and there’s a lot of horse racing to get through. The knowledge of the time of the Calcutta has also faded, hence the fact that I felt the need to explain what one was in the introduction…

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s